Web fiction, read free onlineAll stories: 1 sections

True Health Report

The Love I Stopped Waiting For

Chapter 2

4,956 words

“Ever consider that she’s so calm because she’s sure you’ll go back?”

Jake dropped a slice of tripe into the broth and pulled it out eight seconds later, as precise as a surgeon.

I said nothing.

“You deleted the chat and moved your stuff out, and she didn’t even follow you.” He dipped the tripe in sauce and handed it to me. “Does that sound like someone who’s afraid of losing you?”

“Maybe she thought chasing me wouldn’t help.”

“No. She thought she didn’t need to. After your old fights, what was the longest you stayed away?”

I thought about it. “Three days. Three at most.”

“She’s waiting out your three days,” Jake said.

The broth bubbled, and steam fogged my glasses. I took them off to wipe them, unable to make out his expression.

My phone lit up.

A message from Claire: I’ve thought about it. You’re right. I haven’t given you enough attention lately. Get some rest for a few days. I’ll pick you up this weekend, and we’ll talk properly.

Jake leaned over, read it, and scoffed.

“Stage four of the standard routine. Playing humble.”

“What do you mean?”

“Watch.” He held up four fingers.

“Stage one: anger. Stop being dramatic. She’s already used that. Stage two: shifting blame. We were with coworkers. He posted the picture himself. Stage three: threats. Don’t regret it once you leave. Stage four: backing down. I’ve thought about it. You’re right.”

He counted them off, then looked at me.

“One, two, three, four. Every single one. Even the order’s the same.”

“How do you know so much about this?”

“Three years in the ER. I’ve seen it too many times. The one who got violent gets detained, comes to their senses, and goes through the same four stages. Some people get forgiven at stage four. Then the whole thing starts over at stage one.”

I looked down at the message, started to reply, then set the phone aside.

The next day.

A mutual friend messaged me.

Mark Foster. He was dating one of Claire’s college friends. We’d had dinner together a few times, but we weren’t particularly close.

“Evan, I heard you and Claire had a fight. She’s been pretty out of it today, just sitting in her office staring into space. What happened? Want me to get you two together to talk?”

I replied, “We broke up.”

He sent a string of question marks.

“How did it turn into a breakup? Weren’t you going away together for Thanksgiving?”

“She didn’t come.”

“Didn’t she say she was busy with the project? Their deadline really is brutal. My girlfriend’s been working overtime for days too. Don’t overthink it. This stuff is normal in a relationship.”

Overthinking it.

I turned my phone facedown.

At three that afternoon, Ryan messaged me.

We rarely spoke on Snapchat, but we had each other added.

“Hey, Evan. I heard there’s been a bit of a misunderstanding between you and Claire. That day really was just a team dinner. I was careless with my caption, and I’m really sorry it gave you the wrong idea. Claire and I are just coworkers. You have nothing to worry about.”

I read it twice.

Every word was spotless. Every punctuation mark was perfectly placed. An apology without groveling. A denial without sounding defensive.

Like a PR statement.

I took a screenshot and sent it to Jake.

He replied immediately: “If they really were just coworkers, would some guy at your girlfriend’s company rush to explain himself the second you broke up?”

I looked at the message again and suddenly noticed a detail.

He called her “Claire.”

Not “Ms. Bennett.” Not “your girlfriend.” Not even “she.”

Just “Claire,” with an easy familiarity.

I’d never had to think about how he addressed her before. To me, she was Claire Bennett.

How close did you have to be to someone for their name to sound like an endearment?

Jake sent another message: “Notice how he says he ‘gave you the wrong idea’? Not ‘what I did was wrong.’ The problem is your interpretation. He’s apologizing while implying you’re imagining things.”

I set my phone down.

Another message from Mark: “Evan, Claire asked me to tell you she really knows she messed up. She means it this time. Can’t you give her another chance? It’s been two years. Don’t throw it away over one little thing.”

One little thing.

Not coming when I had a fever was one. Not reading the itinerary was another. Breaking her Thanksgiving promise was another. Separately, each was a “little thing.” But no one wanted to stack them up and see how tall they’d become.

I replied, “Thanks, Mark. But no.”

“You’re way too stubborn. Claire has so much going for her. You think you’ll find someone better once you walk away?”

I stared at that sentence for half a minute.

Then I closed the chat. I didn’t delete it. I didn’t reply.

Jake called.

“Evan, listen to me.”

“Yeah.”

“No matter who contacts you these next few days, no matter what she says, remember one thing. You had a fever of 102.6, and she didn’t come. That isn’t a little thing. It isn’t a misunderstanding. It isn’t you overthinking. It’s a fact.”

“Facts don’t need explaining. Excuses do.”