A Fifty-Dollar Wife, a Million-Dollar Lie
Chapter 1
At noon, I stumbled across an anonymous post my husband had made online.
“My wife’s birthday is coming up. Any decent gift ideas under a hundred bucks?”
He had even saved the top-rated reply.
Just then, a new text popped up on his phone.
“Mr. Hayes, your custom 5.03-carat diamond ring is ready. Please confirm the inscription: ‘To my Chloe.’”
“If everything is correct, we’ll deliver it to your specified address this Friday.”
My heart clenched.
Tomorrow really was my birthday, but he had never called me Chloe.
Pressing a hand to my chest, I replied from his phone.
“Change the delivery address to 118 Ocean Drive.”
That was our home.
I wanted to see exactly who “my Chloe” was.
“Is this 118 Ocean Drive? I have a custom jewelry delivery that requires a signature.”
At ten on Friday morning, the doorbell rang.
The courier held a square black velvet box in both hands.
I took it and glanced down at the delivery slip.
The recipient’s name: Chloe West.
“Mr. Hayes asked us to make sure we handed it directly to a family member.”
“Of course. Thank you.”
After shutting the door, I stood in the entryway for a long time.
Slowly, I opened the box.
5.03 carats. Cushion cut. Exceptional fire. Clarity no lower than VS1.
I had spent three years as an appraiser at Sterling Jewelers. I didn’t need equipment to recognize the quality of this stone.
Its retail value was at least $2.8 million.
The engraving inside the band was perfectly clear: To my Chloe.
I closed the box, set it on the coffee table, and sank onto the couch.
Last night’s scene came back to me.
Ethan had pulled a clear plastic bag from his pocket and handed it to me.
“Your birthday’s coming up, honey. Here’s an early present. Open it.”
Inside was a silver necklace with a heart-shaped pendant. It was so light I could barely feel its weight.
“Picked it out just for you. Pretty, right?”
“Pretty.”
“Good. Took me forever to choose. Harder than writing my year-end report.”
“That much effort? Thank you, Ethan.”
“Come on. You’re my wife.”
His smile had seemed sincere. I had believed him.
But the top-rated reply he’d saved under his anonymous post said: Under a hundred? Just get her a silver necklace off Wish. Women aren’t that hard to keep happy.
Later, I looked up the necklace’s actual price.
Not a hundred dollars.
$58.80, shipping included.
$2.8 million versus $58.80.
More than forty-seven thousand six hundred times as much.
Millie ran out of her bedroom and threw herself into my arms.
“Mommy, it’s your birthday today! Where’s Daddy?”
“On a business trip.”
“Again? He’s not coming home to blow out your candles?”
“He’ll bring a present back. Go play, sweetheart.”
“Okay.”
Once she ran back to her room, I picked up the tablet Ethan had left on the coffee table.
He hadn’t signed out of his email.
The newest message was a reservation confirmation from a resort. Ocean-view suite. Guests: Ethan Hayes and Chloe West. Check-in today, checkout the day after tomorrow.
The second was a payment notice from a luxury florist. Nine hundred ninety-nine red roses had been delivered to the hotel’s front desk. Total: $8,999.
The third confirmed a candlelit dinner for two at a French restaurant, champagne included. Total: $12,800.
There were dozens of similar receipts.
The earliest was dated two autumns ago.
That was the year Millie turned one, when I left Sterling to care for her full-time.
Ethan had said business was slowing down. He told me to lower my credit card limit and switch to store-brand formula.
I had done everything he asked.
Yet even a quick scan of those emails showed that six figures wouldn’t begin to cover what he had spent on Chloe.
Ethan called.
“Hey, honey. I’m here. Everything went smoothly. I’ll be back tomorrow to celebrate your birthday.”
“Okay.”
“Anything you want? I can bring you a gift.”
“No need. The necklace you gave me last night is perfect.”
“All right. Is Millie behaving?”
“She’s fine. Get back to work.”
“Okay. Get some rest. Happy birthday.”
I hung up and found a name in my contacts.
Natalie Reed. An old college friend who practiced family law.
Last year, she had sent a message saying I could call if I ever needed anything. I never had.
She answered on the second ring.
“Claire? You’re actually calling me first?”
“Natalie, I want a divorce.”
“What happened? Take your time.”
“He’s been keeping another woman for at least two years. Today’s my birthday, and he took her to a resort.”
“And I think he may have used my old professional credit line at Sterling to buy her jewelry.”
The other end went silent for three seconds.
“How much?”
“One ring alone is worth $2.8 million. I haven’t finished adding up the rest.”
“Claire, don’t touch anything yet. Preserve everything exactly as it is. Take screenshots and send them to me.”
“One more thing.”
“Tell me.”
“Help me look into someone named Chloe West. I need her address.”
“You’re planning to confront her?”
“Yes.”
“Are you sure you don’t want a couple of days to think?”
I looked at the black box on the coffee table. A $2.8 million token of love, addressed to another woman.
“Find her. Once you have the address, I’ll go myself.”
“I need to see what a woman worth $2.8 million looks like.”